Both cities have taken a hard Covid knock, but Mumbai beats Delhi with data transparency

Covid-19 testing in Delhi | Representational image | Manisha Mondal | ThePrint
Covid-19 testing in Delhi | Representational picture | Manisha Mondal | ThePrint

Textual content Measurement:

Mumbai/New Delhi: Two of India’s most essential cities — nationwide capital Delhi and monetary capital Mumbai — have borne the brunt of the Covid-19 pandemic, with each registering over 1 lakh coronavirus instances. However what units them aside is their strategy in the direction of information. 

Whereas Mumbai routinely places all its Covid-related information on the market, free for perusal by the general public and consultants, the identical can’t be mentioned of Delhi. 

Not solely does Mumbai have an in depth dashboard with details about all its 24 administrative wards, the day by day bulletins issued by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Company (BMC) run into a number of pages, providing granular information.

Delhi has a Covid-19 dashboard as nicely that gives some statistics however is extra within the nature of a listing, which lists the cellphone numbers and addresses of labs, hospitals and so forth, and the rules folks have to comply with. The day by day Delhi bulletin is barely a web page lengthy, and has grown more and more sparse for the reason that preliminary days of the pandemic, when it used to supply a way more detailed image.  

Consultants stress the significance of releasing detailed information, describing it as key to gauging the true scenario on the bottom.

Dr Dileep Mavlankar, director on the Delhi-based Indian Institute of Public Well being, mentioned information in public well being is sort of a thermometer, or some other diagnostic device, and helps devise technique for additional remedy.

Sustaining information is as essential as a CT scan for a affected person or following up of a temperature of an individual. If temperature goes up, it means one thing is unsuitable, if it goes down, it means issues are working,” he added.

We’re deeply grateful to our readers & viewers for his or her time, belief and subscriptions.

High quality journalism is dear and desires readers to pay for it. Your assist will outline our work and ThePrint’s future.


“If there isn’t a correct dependable information, consultants shall be unable to develop a method to counter this pandemic. The extra granular information there’s, the higher.”

Additionally Learn: 57% of Mumbai slum dwellers have been uncovered to Covid, developed antibodies, finds sero survey

Mumbai vs Delhi

Mumbai has up to now recorded 1,14,287 Covid-19 instances, with 87,074 recoveries, 20,569 lively instances and 6,350 deaths as of Friday. In Delhi, there have been 1,35,598 Covid-19 instances, with 10,705 lively instances, 1,20,930 recoveries, and three,963 deaths.

As of 1 June, Delhi was issuing detailed bulletins that provided a break-up of optimistic instances (lively and recovered), sufferers admitted in numerous hospitals and Covid care centres, age break-up, and cumulative exams performed. On some days, the small print of pending lab reviews have been additionally supplied. Nonetheless, even these lacked district-wise information.

Now, all of the bulletin provides is the variety of optimistic instances (whole and day by day replace), the variety of beds — occupied and vacant — at Covid-19 services, and the variety of exams performed. On some days in Could and June, no well being bulletin was issued in any respect.

The dashboard at opens with a smattering of statistics just like the variety of lively instances, deaths, recoveries and testing charge. Additional in, you’ll be able to test the provision of beds at totally different hospitals and the areas earmarked as containment zones, however there’s little different information on the developments of the illness within the nationwide capital.

The Mumbai dashboard at, in the meantime, supplies granular information underneath a number of verticals — variety of high-risk, symptomatic, asymptomatic and demanding sufferers in every of the town’s 24 wards, whole lively instances, deaths, positivity charge, and ICU beds accessible in hospitals, contact-tracing executed within the final 24 hours (the variety of contacts traced, and, if they’ve examined optimistic, what number of of them are in residence and institutional quarantine), exams performed, lab reviews pending, containment zones declared, and constructing/areas sealed.

The BMC began work on the dashboard in Could and it turned practical on 7 June.

Though charts with these information factors are fed into the dashboard, the BMC additionally points a really complete well being bulletin day by day that has particulars on deaths, variety of instances, general development charge of an infection, doubling charge, and availability of hospital beds.

Additionally Learn: Dharavi’s surprising Covid success story has classes for Delhi, different crowded cities

Mumbai working with ward-level battle rooms

Know-how and self-discipline are the 2 key drivers of Mumbai’s information administration.

Mumbai has been in a position to handle its voluminous information by dividing it into a number of verticals, every of which is taken care of by two folks. There are 24 separate ward-level battle rooms, managed by technical and information consultants.

Each morning, the important battle room on the BMC downloads the info of optimistic instances from the ICMR web site, the place it’s uploaded by totally different labs. An algorithm then kinds this information by pincode, and ward-wise information is subsequently dispatched to the 24 wards for follow-up.

The ward-level battle rooms… are manned 24 hours (a day) by three totally different groups that comprise resident docs, medical college students, lecturers and another workers,” Mumbai Municipal Company (BMC) Extra Municipal Commissioner Ashwini Bhide mentioned.

As soon as the ward receives the listing, they name up individuals who have turned optimistic to ask how they’re feeling. If they’re unwell, they’re referred to hospitals, if they’re asymptomatic, the crew visits and checks them with oximeters (gadgets that test oxygen ranges within the blood stream) after which decides if they need to be shifted to hospital or allowed to remain in residence isolation,” she added.

Having these battle rooms has helped Mumbai streamline information, she mentioned.

Initially, there was no system in place to gather the knowledge coming from all hospitals. In a while, we recognized these verticals and determined the possession of every so that there’s accountability. The particular person answerable for information on exams owns that vertical. The one answerable for information on deaths or lively instances makes positive that’s up to date,” Bhide added.

After sorting these verticals, we then had a horizontal pipeline connecting all these to a central system, which may go immediately within the dashboard,” she mentioned.

What has aided Mumbai’s strategy is streamlining information enter. To keep away from confusion, the authorities outfitted testing labs and hospitals with a template for information submission into the ICMR portal.

Earlier reviews didn’t embrace cellphone numbers, addresses, they solely had names, and it created an excessive amount of confusion. We then created a normal Google type with all of the required heads, which the labs and hospitals now fill,” Bhide mentioned.

In Delhi, there isn’t a devoted centralised battle room. The district magistrates of its 11 districts have been managing information with the assistance of chief district medical officers.

Accredited social well being activists (ASHAs) gather affected person particulars (age, signs, gender and so forth) from the bottom and go them on to the medical officers involved, who then share the info with the DMs.

There was no centralised system for information from day one and the well being division relies on information despatched by DMs,” a DM advised ThePrint.

Some districts like South Delhi have a devoted battle room, the place information from the realm is collected and uploaded on a Covid portal. Nonetheless, the portal can solely be accessed by authorities officers.

ThePrint made a number of makes an attempt by means of calls and texts to get a remark for this report from Delhi Director Normal of Well being Companies Nutan Mundeja, Well being Minister Satyendar Jain, and the workplace of Well being Secretary Padmini Singla, however hadn’t acquired a response till the time of publishing.

Additionally Learn: Human problem trials for Covid vaccine pointless, unethical — Fauci at ICMR symposium

A correct format to keep away from confusion

The Mumbai dashboard additionally provides real-time information on standing of vital, symptomatic and asymptomatic sufferers, one other perform carried out by the ward-level battle rooms that continually monitor sufferers’ remedy.

The sufferers maintain shifting. Some asymptomatic sufferers go to Covid care centres. In the event that they get vital, they’re shifted to devoted Covid hospitals. Some are despatched residence. All that is tracked by our ward-level groups and the numbers up to date commonly,” Bhide mentioned.

No such info is out there in Delhi. In response to Bhide, the system they’ve devised has additionally helped them plug holes in information.

After we began this ward-level system, we may monitor all hospitals carefully and located that quite a lot of deaths weren’t being reported. That can also be due to the pending documentation. Now, all hospitals have been given a Google type and a dying abstract format,” Bhide mentioned.

Covid fatality figures in Delhi, in the meantime, have been underneath a cloud since Could, with discrepant figures coming from funeral properties, municipal businesses and the Delhi authorities giving rise to allegations that the latter could also be under-reporting deaths.

Talking to ThePrint off the document, Delhi authorities officers have denied the cost, blaming the mismatch on the time it takes for the figures to be tallied and verified by the audit committee. Even so, no effort has been made to streamline the circulate of information. As lately as 17 July, there was a discrepancy of 500 between the info of civic businesses and that of the Delhi authorities.

On 2 July, ThePrint had reported discrepancies within the information for Mumbai Covid deaths launched by the Maharashtra authorities and the BMC too, however the state information was simply off by two. 

Monitoring the provision of beds

The absence of real-time information on the provision of hospital beds initially proved an enormous problem in Mumbai because it discovered itself overwhelmed by coronavirus, however the BMC has since addressed this concern.

There are two issues we monitor — current beds getting crammed and beds being added. All the pieces has to go on the dashboard each day,” Bhide mentioned. “This additionally is finished on a ward degree, the place an in depth watch is saved on beds occupied, accessible in Covid care services. All this info comes from all wards each day and is up to date in actual time,” she mentioned.

It was with an analogous intention that the Delhi authorities launched an app — Delhi Corona — in June that seeks to supply real-time updates on mattress availability, however the portal has courted allegations of mismatch since day one. 

Additionally Learn: Delhi Covid graph exhibits declining development, however consultants say it’s early to say peak has handed

Cleaned up the mess’

As a way to arrange its battle rooms, Mumbai engaged non-public gamers like PwC.

To achieve their present degree of transparency, Bhide mentioned, they needed to overcome a number of hurdles. “We’ve got developed. Initially, we weren’t positive about our personal information. Lab information was not correct, addresses have been unsuitable. We’ve got cleaned up the mess,” she mentioned.

There are some points that crop up even now, however we take all strategies and incorporate them,” she added.

Transparency, Bhide mentioned, is essential for their very own development.

Numbers don’t lie. Sustaining clear information is essential for us, so we all know the place the shoe is pinching. With out this, we might not have been in a position to management the scenario or resolve points,” she added.

Additionally Learn: Elevate lockdowns, shield the susceptible, deal with Covid like a well being difficulty and never a catastrophe


Subscribe to our channels on YouTube & Telegram

Information media is in a disaster & solely you’ll be able to repair it

You’re studying this since you worth good, clever and goal journalism. We thanks in your time and your belief.

You additionally know that the information media is going through an unprecedented disaster. It’s doubtless that you’re additionally listening to of the brutal layoffs and pay-cuts hitting the trade. There are lots of the explanation why the media’s economics is damaged. However an enormous one is that good individuals are not but paying sufficient for good journalism.

We’ve got a newsroom full of gifted younger reporters. We even have the nation’s most sturdy modifying and fact-checking crew, most interesting information photographers and video professionals. We’re constructing India’s most formidable and energetic information platform. And we aren’t even three but.

At ThePrint, we put money into high quality journalists. We pay them pretty and on time even on this tough interval. As you’ll have seen, we don’t flinch from spending no matter it takes to ensure our reporters attain the place the story is. Our stellar coronavirus protection is an effective instance. You possibly can test a few of it right here.

This comes with a large price. For us to proceed bringing high quality journalism, we’d like readers such as you to pay for it. As a result of the promoting market is damaged too.

When you suppose we deserve your assist, do be part of us on this endeavour to strengthen truthful, free, brave, and questioning journalism, please click on on the hyperlink beneath. Your assist will outline our journalism, and ThePrint’s future. It’s going to take just some seconds of your time.

Help Our Journalism

You May Also Like

About the Author:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *